Retrograde Nelson

The ascendency of Russell M. Nelson to the presidency of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints on January 14, 2018 was met in some corners with fear and trembling. In a post at the popular blog By Common Consent that was eventually deleted, one blogger flatly declared that “President Nelson is particularly unfit for the office of President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.” This blogger was adamant that “President Nelson bears unique responsibility for the [November 5, 2015 policy on same-sex couples] and for the innocent blood that has been spilled as a direct result of its continued existence.” While still sustaining him as President of the Church and expressing desire to afford him some measure of patience and charity, this blogger questioned whether God “orchestrated President Nelson’s call to the First Presidency” and hopefully reminded his readers that the “chances are very very [sic] good that you will outlive President Nelson.”1

Similar sentiment was, to varying degrees, expressed in other parts of the Internet. President Nelson, it was widely assumed, would retrench the Church in old school fundamentalism, double down on “Mormon” racism and homophobia, and fossilize institutional practices and hierarchical structures.

A headline from NBC News at the time of President Nelson’s confirmation as Church President that has not particularly aged well.

It has now been one year, one month, and six days since Russell M. Nelson assumed leadership of the Church. Let’s review just some of what has transpired under his tenure as President of the Church during this time.

  • 23 January 2018: The Church creates social media ads encouraging sensitivity to concerns of LGBT members.
  • 26 January 2018: The Church signals apprehension of President Donald Trump’s immigration policies.
  • 20 February 2018: The Church works with Utah legislators to curb teen suicide in the state.
  • 7 February 2018: The Church’s Family Services informs the Deseret News that it “do[es] not provide what is commonly referred to as ‘reparative therapy’ or ‘sexual orientation change efforts.'”
  • 23 February 2018: President Nelson laments lax gun control laws which “allow guns to go to people who shouldn’t have them.”
  • 2 March 2018: Bishop Gérald Caussé addresses Church finances.
  • 31 March 2018: President Nelson announces restructuring of priesthood quorums.
  • 31 March 2018: President Nelson appoints two new apostles to the Quorum of the Twelve, including the quorum’s first Asian-American and Brazilian members.
  • 1 April 2018: Home and Visiting Teaching is replaced with “Ministering.”
  • 24 April 2018: The Church donates money to Utah’s teen suicide prevention effort.
  • 11 May 2018 (23 August 2018 / 4 October 2018): The Church initially opposes Utah’s medical marijuana initiative but then works out a “good faith” compromise.
  • 17 May 2018: President Nelson meets with leaders of the NAACP in an effort to promote “greater civility, racial and ethnic harmony and mutual respect.”
  • 1 June 2018: The Church holds a special commemoration of the 1978 revelation on priesthood. At the event President Nelson speaks of his “desire to build bridges of cooperation instead of walls of segregation.”
  • 18 June 2018: Church leaders denounce President Trump’s immigration policies as “harmful.”
  • 18 June 2018: Church announces plans for a new hymnal that will include “music of local interest in each language.”
  • 20 June 2018: Church leaders implement “new guidelines for interviewing youth”
  • 22 June 2018: Missionary curriculum revised to add more humanizing touch.
  • 28 June 2018: The Tabernacle Choir at Temple Square (formerly the Mormon Tabernacle Choir) holds rehearsal with San Francisco Gay Men’s Chorus.
  • 10 July 2018: The Church makes a “historic” donation “to an LGBTQ support group to pay for suicide prevention training.”
  • 15 July 2018: “LDS Church, NAACP to launch joint education, employment initiative”
  • 4 September 2018: The Church publishes the first volume of “Saints: The Story of the Church of Jesus Christ in the Latter Days.”
  • 17 September 2018: New members are called to the Relief Society, Young Women and Primary general boards, including “two black women, [and] ‘Common Ground’ LGBT inclusion advocate”
  • 6 October 2018: Church leaders meet with NAACP leaders once again to foster “greater civility and racial harmony.” On this occasion the two groups “announce efforts for expanded collaboration between the members of the two organizations.”
  • 6 October 2018: President Nelson opens General Conference by announcing new Church-wide curriculum aimed at providing “new balance and connection between gospel instruction in the home and in the Church.” A new two-hour-long schedule for Church meetings on Sunday is announced.
  • 10 October 2018: Elder Steven E. Snow encourages Church members “give high priority to how they treat all of God’s creations.”
  • 29 October 2018: The Church condemns anti-Semitism and violence in response to the Tree of Life Synagogue shooting.
  • 2 November 2018: Church leaders host NCAA leaders and “bring together LGBTQ advocates and athletic administrators, largely from faith-based institutions, to explore the issues of religious freedom and sexual orientation on college campuses in the United States.”
  • 14 December 2018: The First Presidency announces age changes for youth progression and priesthood ordination.
  • 20 December 2018: The Church announces new dress standards for sister missionaries.
  • 1 January 2019: The First Presidency issues a statement on the nature of temple ordinances coinciding with new changes to said ordinances received warmly by many “faithful feminists.”
  • 24 January 2019: The First Presidency states in a letter that deceased endowed Latter-day Saint women are not required to be veiled at the time of burial.
  • 15 February 2019: The First Presidency announces that missionaries may call home weekly.
  • 19 February 2019: President Nelson expresses concern with immigration policies that separate families at the border. “We are to keep families together and not separate families.”
  • 20 February 2019: The Church announces it will not oppose proposed legislation in the Utah state legislature banning gay “conversion therapy” and “denounces any therapy including conversion or reparative therapies that subject individuals to abusive practices.”

Observing this trend prompted a friend and I to coin a meme we call “Retrograde Nelson” (also a hashtag). The meme ironically highlights what are rather progressive and, if you will, “woke” comments and policy actions by the supposed retrograde and regressive President Nelson. At several points my friend and I shared these headlines with each other with the comment “looks like Retrograde Nelson strikes again!” to punctuate our amusement with President Nelson’s incongruous and unexpected wokeness (so-perceived).

To be sure, the Church has not become some sort of Progressive bastion. And for many, nothing short of full LGBT and gender equality in the Church (in matters pertaining to, say, temple sealings and priesthood ordination) will be sufficient. Be that as it may, one cannot help but feel that some of the more dramatic caterwauling heard back at the time of President Nelson’s appointment as Church President was perhaps overblown. While the Church under President Nelson may not be as Progressive as a Portland vegan dinner party hosted by Hillary Clinton and Cecile Richards, it is nowhere close to being some kind of Handmaid’s Tale-esque dystopian nightmare. Not by any feasible stretch of the imagination.

Postscript: At the recommendation of a friend, I am going to continue updating the list of President Nelson’s regressive and retrograde policy actions.

  • 27 February 2019: The Church “Donates $2 Million to the International African American Museum.”
  • 1 March 2019: The Church “remove[s] the restrictions on mothers” serving as ordinance workers in temples.
  • 1 March 2019: President Nelson meets with Pope Francis and stresses ecumenical cooperation and friendship.
  • 4 April 2019: The November 2015 policy on same-sex couples and their children is rescinded.
  • 6 May 2019: The policy of making civilly-married couples wait one year until getting sealed in the temple is rescinded.
  • 11 May 2019: “Church Honors NAACP for Advancing Equality and Justice in Society”
  • 15 May 2019: “Church Provides $4 Million Donation to US Refugee Resettlement Agencies”
  • 20 May 2019: “President Nelson Meets with New Zealand Prime Minister” and mentions how he is “impressed” with her leadership.
  • 21 May 2019: President Nelson donates $100,000 to the Islamic community in New Zealand to help rebuild local mosques after a terrorist attack in Christchurch.
  • 21 July 2019: President Nelson speaks at the NAACP’s national meeting. Rev. Amos C. Brown of the NAACP says of President Nelson: “The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, under the leadership of President Russell M. Nelson, is here tonight to say to the NAACP, ‘We are going to lock arms with you to fight racism’. . . . He’s here to help us do a heart transplant for the nation.”

  1. Since the blog post was taken down I felt it would be discourteous to give the author attribution. Nevertheless, this blogger publicly said the things they did, and I have no real reason to think they have backed down from their position. On the contrary, I have very good reason to think this particular blogger has the same opinion today as they did when they originally posted these comments. I may of course be mistaken, but I don’t think I am.

6 thoughts on “Retrograde Nelson”

  1. “For many |progressives], nothing short of full LGBT and gender equality in the Church (in matters pertaining to, say, temple sealings and priesthood ordination) will be sufficient.”

    As an observer of the progressive movement, I would dispute this. NOTHING will be sufficient, because the nature of progressivism is to continually move the goal posts and agitate for change. Give them what they demand and they’ll only demand more.

    (Terrific post, by the way!)

  2. The breath of fresh air Nelson has brought to the Church would make my Grandfather proud. A Pastor in the Church, he was such a gentle, accepting man, the changes in doctrine would have met with his approval.

  3. I don’t believe President Nelson is changing the doctrine at all. He is merely teaching and warning us to be more Christ like in our interaction and inclusion if all. Christ showed love for all his fellow men, women and children alike regardless of who they were. He had love for his brothers and sisters in the gospel as well as enemies, sinners, leper’s and those cast aside by others, but he never changed the doctrine of God while doing it. Being inclusive to all is not a doctrinal change it is a way of living the doctrines already in place. This is my belief. I love that President Nelson is showing us how to truly be disciples of Christ and love all. Thanks for sharing the updates to how we should be living our principles this is a wonderful space.

  4. I grew up seeing all the positive changes made under President Kimball, now I welcome all the changes President Nelson is bringing. I see it as streamlining, focusing, and moving forward. I hope he lives and presides for another twenty years.

  5. And for those of us old enough to remember when Spencer Kimball became Church president, we recall that the major media outlets of the time were as critically dismissive of him as are the progressives of today condescendingly critical of President Nelson.

    Most media portrayed Elder Kimball as a feeble man with no voice and hide-bound, blinkered attitudes that would move the Church nowhere. At least the poor health of this diminutive, weak man would not allow him to serve for very long as its leader. Therefore, most reports focused instead on the prominent powerhouse coming behind Kimball, namely Ezra Taft Benson.

    How’d that turn out for all the smart kids?

    And then, of course, Benson was portrayed as a dire threat to the unity of the Church given his extreme right-leaning politics. Surely when he came to power he would subjugate us all to McCarthyism and the John Birch Society.

    Instead, we got a prophetic voice that gave impetus to the finest Book of Mormon study and scholarship done since Joseph returned the plates to the angel.

    And now I’m supposed to be swayed by these current nimrods’ opinions of what President Nelson will do?

Leave a Comment